The class critique went differently than i expected. I am not an art major, so i dont really have them that often, so maybe that's whay i didnt get what i expected. I did not really find the critique that beneficial for 2 reasons. 1) I got very little feedback on the actual craftsmanship of my piece, and since i am not continuing with this piece, the other feedback seemed of little use to my future as an artist and 2) the focus of almost everything was on the joke that i had incorperated into the piece as an after thought instead of my main concept. The cold feedback I got was great. it showed that my piece properly conveyed my message that if we mix natural and artificial intelligence disasterous things can happen. I wanted to show an exploded head as the disaster, because if that were to happen to an actual person it would be. unfortunately, i did lose some of the pieces of scalp, so that did detract from the piece, and i could not splatter the fake blood everywhere, for it stains terribly (i was scrubbing the floor in the crit space, and it is still stained red), so that was not great either. Also, I left the brain in tact, because i felt that if it were in pieces it wouldnt convey my message properly. and, it was only the head that was supposed to have exploded, not the inner contents.I really did like the idea of having an eyeball on the side as part of the explosion, and if i were to do this again, i definately would incorperate that. I also would also make a bust instead of just the top of a head so that would be more obvious. I also would not even bother mentioning the joke, because it was barely even a part of the piece and was just taken wrong. Apparently I didnt convey my concept well when talking about it, and that is def something i can improve on for the next critique.
Ashley's shoes obviously showed a lot of work and attention to detail. Her shelves were a nice extra touch, as were the boxes with the individual labels. She obviously put a lot of care into all the details. One place where I saw room for improvement was mentioned in class--that the boxes were not obvious, and should be displayed with the shoes. Another place was with the darker boots--i believe they were supposed to be snakeskin. the insides looked unfinished compared to the rest of the shoes. I would have liked to see all the pieces glazed, but i do understand that to get the right textures that wsnt possible, but it would have been nice none the less. the concept however was not immediately obvious with her piece. I suppose that since many shoes now a days have animal prints, that aspect did not stand out. even then, I wasnt sure if the shoes were representing real animals as the label suggested), or if they were supposed to be a statement againts animal skins for fashion. that would be something to consider making more evident for the next piece. Overall good craftsmanship and great display!
Thursday, November 1, 2007
In response to the critique, I really liked the way it was run. I think it is always a good idea to have the artist let people respond to the piece first and then talk about their project and what direction they were heading in. As far as my project goes, it was nice to hear people actually telling the truth rather than just pretending to like it. Although I was kind of disappointed that people were focusing more on the hospital bed presentation rather than the actual piece itself and I don't know if that's my fault or just different peoples way of interpreting it. Overall I was pretty disappointed with my piece and I don't plan on taking it any further. I tried my best but unfortunately the idea in my head didn't match the finished project.
Kat's piece
When I first looked at Kat's piece I interpreted it as more of a tree rather than a brain. But then the more I looked at and saw the visual clues like the gel, I realized it had to be something else. I really enjoyed how there was so much movement to it with each twist and curve in the structure and also the way the gel moved down the pedestal. The gel definitely added a softer texture to it as opposed the brain which had a smoker’s lung effect from the glaze. Whether or not this piece was supposed to be touched, many people were drawn in by the gel and ended up touching it which was a great way to keep people interested in the piece. My favorite part of the piece was the area at the bottom of the brain where the gel met and the brain and sort of magnified the areas it was on top of.
Kat's piece
When I first looked at Kat's piece I interpreted it as more of a tree rather than a brain. But then the more I looked at and saw the visual clues like the gel, I realized it had to be something else. I really enjoyed how there was so much movement to it with each twist and curve in the structure and also the way the gel moved down the pedestal. The gel definitely added a softer texture to it as opposed the brain which had a smoker’s lung effect from the glaze. Whether or not this piece was supposed to be touched, many people were drawn in by the gel and ended up touching it which was a great way to keep people interested in the piece. My favorite part of the piece was the area at the bottom of the brain where the gel met and the brain and sort of magnified the areas it was on top of.
Critique of Rebecca's first project
(In this review, I am taking into consideration that this creative work is an academic endeavor in response to a course assignment about considering "nature and manmade; and what makes something natural versus artificial" )
Rebecca's gory piece was a finished mixed media piece with a core of fired, brightly glazed ceramic form representing the split two hemispheres of a human brain, with real and colorful wires attached and spilling out from its ceramic bowl, representing a broken skull. The central piece was embellished with patches of "scalp" and human hair strewn about. The piece was presented upright on the floor with a perfect circle of splattered blood stains around it.
It is very clear that the brain,skull,scalp and hair were the natural component and the electrical wires were the manmade component. What was not clear, was the cause of the broken skull with the splattered blood, the explosion and destruction of the brain with its wires attached. It was also not clear what the relationship of the wires to the brain was. The viewer is left with lots of uncomfortable questions in attempting to understand the piece: Was it attacked by a vicious predator? Was this the brain of an insane person who was "hardwired" to self destruct? Did the wires represent some sort of spreading matrix of lethal metatasis of a cancer? Was it some sort of electric shock treatment gone horribly wrong? Clarity on the concept came from the artist: the piece was about a dumb blond, whose brain exploded from information overload...it was meant to be a play on the old dumb blond jokes. But considering there was actually a brain there (and not an empty air head )we actually see a blond with a brain. Unfortunately , perhaps because I am a blond, I fail to see how that concept addresses nature versus manmade.
The brain and the bowl skull were well crafted but looked a bit too intact
to be effective as the result of an explosion. If part of the brain spilled out of a more lopsided bowl, the effect of an explosion could have enhanced. Had the blood been in a less perfect circle and a more chaotic it also would have conveyed the idea of an explosion. Had the brain been on top of a torso with long flowing blond hair, dressed as a self centered image-conscious female body, it may have conveyed the idea of a dumb blond better. As a whole,the construction was symmetrical and orderly and probably would not have held my attention if I had seen it in another setting. Shock value alone never holds my interest.
In spite of appreciating the evidence of much time, work and full use of the entire ceramic process by Rebecca, I question whether she has really conveyed her concept and I question if she really addressed the question of nature versus artificial as assigned.
Rebecca's gory piece was a finished mixed media piece with a core of fired, brightly glazed ceramic form representing the split two hemispheres of a human brain, with real and colorful wires attached and spilling out from its ceramic bowl, representing a broken skull. The central piece was embellished with patches of "scalp" and human hair strewn about. The piece was presented upright on the floor with a perfect circle of splattered blood stains around it.
It is very clear that the brain,skull,scalp and hair were the natural component and the electrical wires were the manmade component. What was not clear, was the cause of the broken skull with the splattered blood, the explosion and destruction of the brain with its wires attached. It was also not clear what the relationship of the wires to the brain was. The viewer is left with lots of uncomfortable questions in attempting to understand the piece: Was it attacked by a vicious predator? Was this the brain of an insane person who was "hardwired" to self destruct? Did the wires represent some sort of spreading matrix of lethal metatasis of a cancer? Was it some sort of electric shock treatment gone horribly wrong? Clarity on the concept came from the artist: the piece was about a dumb blond, whose brain exploded from information overload...it was meant to be a play on the old dumb blond jokes. But considering there was actually a brain there (and not an empty air head )we actually see a blond with a brain. Unfortunately , perhaps because I am a blond, I fail to see how that concept addresses nature versus manmade.
The brain and the bowl skull were well crafted but looked a bit too intact
to be effective as the result of an explosion. If part of the brain spilled out of a more lopsided bowl, the effect of an explosion could have enhanced. Had the blood been in a less perfect circle and a more chaotic it also would have conveyed the idea of an explosion. Had the brain been on top of a torso with long flowing blond hair, dressed as a self centered image-conscious female body, it may have conveyed the idea of a dumb blond better. As a whole,the construction was symmetrical and orderly and probably would not have held my attention if I had seen it in another setting. Shock value alone never holds my interest.
In spite of appreciating the evidence of much time, work and full use of the entire ceramic process by Rebecca, I question whether she has really conveyed her concept and I question if she really addressed the question of nature versus artificial as assigned.
The critique process yesterday was much more informative than I have ever experienced in my ceramics classes here at UD. I learned how much more practice you all have had at presentation! I appreciate that the instructor tried to involve everyone in the process and that she kept us thinking about how to ask and look at things. I do wonder at just how far away from the original assignment some people strayed....the instructor seemed to allow these interpretations of her question " what makes something natural and what makes it artificial? " but I wonder whether some of the pieces actually addressed that issue as assigned?
Realizing that "conceptual" is a big deal around here, I was not surprised to see a lack of balance of interesting composition of most of the exhibit . I was however, rather surprised to learn that very few of the concepts were actually conveyed as the creator intended. It seems that the concept is just a spring board or a starting point for creating a piece. Since the answer to my question, "Does it matter that no one understands your concept? does it bother you? " was usually "No, let the audience interpret as they will", it sort of begs the question: what is the point of conceptual if you can't convey the concept?
After reading our assignment and links about art critics, I am convinced that it should be impressed upon art students to consider FORM, DESIGN, COMPOSITION, BALANCE, VALUES,LINE, PROPORTION,RHYTHM and SPACE/JUXTAPOSITION, NUANCES and CRAFTSMANSHIP /SKILL if we are to actually consider a creative work, a piece of art.
Realizing that "conceptual" is a big deal around here, I was not surprised to see a lack of balance of interesting composition of most of the exhibit . I was however, rather surprised to learn that very few of the concepts were actually conveyed as the creator intended. It seems that the concept is just a spring board or a starting point for creating a piece. Since the answer to my question, "Does it matter that no one understands your concept? does it bother you? " was usually "No, let the audience interpret as they will", it sort of begs the question: what is the point of conceptual if you can't convey the concept?
After reading our assignment and links about art critics, I am convinced that it should be impressed upon art students to consider FORM, DESIGN, COMPOSITION, BALANCE, VALUES,LINE, PROPORTION,RHYTHM and SPACE/JUXTAPOSITION, NUANCES and CRAFTSMANSHIP /SKILL if we are to actually consider a creative work, a piece of art.
Dan Rucker- 3rd Blog Assignment
Part I
I thought that yesterdays critique went very well. Everyone was participating and had great feedback. As a class, the crit space looked amazing. It was filled with various types of ceramic projects that really looked professional. I liked the structure of the crit, with the cold feedback coming first and then questions and answers after. I think formatting the critique like this helps to really get an idea for what is going through peoples heads when they look at your work. Especially for my type of artwork,which is at first confusing because it doesn't involve recognizable objects, its good to know that people may be confused but can at least have an idea as to what i was trying to do with the piece. After hearing the feedback about how people wanted to see my piece in large scale, it has only motivated me more to work on my second piece.
Part II
Larkins, project was very intriguing. Initially when I saw the piece I was curious to understand the meaning behind such an odd paring of objects. A log, and an electrical cord are never normally associated with each other unless its trying to tell us something. The concept of the draining of power/ energy and the switch from natural to artificial is defined in Larkins piece. Her ideas were well thought out and applied to the clay. Technically, the log looked very realistic. The scale of the log did not bother me. It wasn't necessary a massive stump, but it also wasn't a dinky little twig either. The electrical cord was well done as well. I like how it was black and not some other random color. It added to the level of realism. The plug was a bit larger than your average, but the size allowed viewers to identify what it was right away. The cord /coil was also well shaped and positioned and showed no cracking along the bends. All in all the project was well done, I cant really pinpoint anything that was wrong with the project. The craft was clean, the concept matched the piece, and it was a simple and aesthetically pleasing design.
I thought that yesterdays critique went very well. Everyone was participating and had great feedback. As a class, the crit space looked amazing. It was filled with various types of ceramic projects that really looked professional. I liked the structure of the crit, with the cold feedback coming first and then questions and answers after. I think formatting the critique like this helps to really get an idea for what is going through peoples heads when they look at your work. Especially for my type of artwork,which is at first confusing because it doesn't involve recognizable objects, its good to know that people may be confused but can at least have an idea as to what i was trying to do with the piece. After hearing the feedback about how people wanted to see my piece in large scale, it has only motivated me more to work on my second piece.
Part II
Larkins, project was very intriguing. Initially when I saw the piece I was curious to understand the meaning behind such an odd paring of objects. A log, and an electrical cord are never normally associated with each other unless its trying to tell us something. The concept of the draining of power/ energy and the switch from natural to artificial is defined in Larkins piece. Her ideas were well thought out and applied to the clay. Technically, the log looked very realistic. The scale of the log did not bother me. It wasn't necessary a massive stump, but it also wasn't a dinky little twig either. The electrical cord was well done as well. I like how it was black and not some other random color. It added to the level of realism. The plug was a bit larger than your average, but the size allowed viewers to identify what it was right away. The cord /coil was also well shaped and positioned and showed no cracking along the bends. All in all the project was well done, I cant really pinpoint anything that was wrong with the project. The craft was clean, the concept matched the piece, and it was a simple and aesthetically pleasing design.
Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)















