Sunday, November 4, 2007

Crtique responses and Dead Dogs!

Holy late post!

I found that there was plenty of excellent feedback thrown about during our critique last week. I definitely received excellent comments, suggestions, tips, etc. It is nice having such a large class because it allows one to hear a large quantity of views about their work. The dialogue between the various members of the class was also quite excellent. WITH THAT BEING SAID: the fact that we have such a large class does mean that there is a lot of ground to cover in only a few hours, and I think that in future critiques a set time limit per piece will help move things along so that we don't have rush through the last 6 pieces, and so that we don't get stuck talking about one piece for 20 minutes. Overall I would consider it to be a pretty solid crit. Whammy!


Anywho (not a real word), in response to Tracy's piece (animal heads and convenient chair), I enjoyed the idea of creating an experience for the viewer, and leading them to view your piece in a certain way (the chair). Directing the viewer to look at your piece a particular way is a great way to enforce an idea, and I think that was executed very well. The fur on "Fluffykins" (spelling?) was downright slammin', however in comparison, it made "Dawg"seem considerably less realistic. This distracted me a bit because it left me wondering if I was to view the animal heads as realistic, or as the heads of stuffed animals. The fact that there were only two made this ambiguity seem unintentional. The names alluded a personal connection between the artist/viewer and the animal heads, which added a personal connotation to the piece. With that said, I would have liked to have seen more (cliche comment, I know, my bad) in addition to some variance in the look of the animals because they looked a little too similar. Also, the fact that every piece on that wall had two parts to it cause the animal heads to stand out a bit less, and I know this was out of you control and that blows, but it had to be said.

Critique

In the critique on Wednesday i got a positive feed back from my classmates. I feel that the response that was given to my piece was what i wanted. It also intrigued me that some people were more interested in the project before i told them what the idea was behind it. I would think that if people knew about the actual agent orange they would feel more strongly. I did benefit from the critique but i felt that it dragged on at some points but overall it was good.
To respond to Kerri's work i have to be honest. I don't want you to think that i am being mean its just how i feel on this particular subject. As i though about the nature vs. non nature i though of the plastic surgery idea but i felt so strongly against it because i have seen it done here in college so many times.I think that your work was one of the better representations but it has come up over and over again and not only do i see it done by students but it is shoved in our face all the time on TV. However besides the idea i like the way you presented the piece. Having it in the dark makes it an intimate object that the viewer has to come close to it and get personal with it. Also having it displayed on the hospital bed also played a key role to how we saw it, without that though i don't think that it would of been as strong.

Saturday, November 3, 2007

Kat's blog and critique response to Dan's work

i was surprised by how well the critique went and how much everyone was talking. i felt that i was really helpful for my own piece and i got to hear how people felt about my work and what came to their mind. it made me question the importance of it being known it is a brain and if that subject really matters. from the talk i liked the idea of extending the trunk of the brain and making it start from the floor and maybe go up higher. i would also maybe have a larger amount of goo all over the place.

Dan's piece was very structural and created many view points. i liked how the holes of the one wall would create a different view and show the other holes in the other wall. Dan's mixture of media was unique in our class and i think really added to the work. i think it would be cool one day to see this work life size because when i look at it i want to walk around among the walls. the pictures of Dan's work are extremely interesting because you can't really tell the size and the colors look amazing. i think in time it be interesting to see if this project could grow into a bigger larger version with clay and other mixed media.

Friday, November 2, 2007

The critique and Dan's piece: by catherine hendrickson (sorry if it posted twice!

I thought Dan's piece was amazing- the concept of a performance piece was especially unique and intriging. I looked at his piece when i first walked in the critic room and admired it for only a few seconds. While he was discussing it during critique I took time to further examine it however, not to the extent I wish I would have. Dan moved closer to it and picked it up; then before I knew it, it was gone. He dropped it on the ground and it was gone forever. I felt a saddness after the initial shock because I realized it would longer exist in the world as it once had and for some reason that really hit me hard. That realization made me appreciate the piece even more.

The critique went very well overall- It was much more insightful for me to do a class critique with the pieces displayed and not just have the artist talk about the piece as it sits on a desk in class. The gallery space was almost crucial in order for all of the pieces to be seen to their full potential. I enjoyed every piece in different ways from the full body to Tisa'a work, to the tree stump! All of the pieces were well thought out.
I enjoyed Ben's piece the most- it really seemed to capture my imagination. I found it interesting how my take on the piece was very different from most of the other class's take but that's also something that makes the piece most interesting- It has the possibility for many interpretations. I loved how the piece had the wire wrappede around it as an added effect- it not only portrayed the sucking in of one of the faces, but it also pulled in the attention of viewers. Very nice work, Ben! I though all of the pieces in the show were great!

Crit overview/ response to Catherine's Masks

Ashley Hamilton

The critique was overall beneficial for me. I understand time was an issue so by the end of class things seemed to be pretty rushed, but I still was able to get some useful information from the crit. I was surprised that no one even commented on the subject matter of my piece (maybe for lack of time, again?) Something I found useful was the suggestion of placing the boxes underneath the shoes. This allowed viewers to more easily understand my project (although I don’t think it is as visually pleasing or realistically convincing). The critique made me realize that my piece did not successfully convey my message of animal rights, and I would have to rethink my concept if I were to display this piece again. On the contraire, I think the piece was cohesive as a work of art (minus the subject matter) and could still stand on its own purely for craftsmanship and the detail which keeps the viewer’s interest. I wish everyone would talk even more at critiques, and also that we would split the time equally so that no one felt rushed during their personal work’s critique.


Overall I enjoyed Catherine’s piece visually. I think conceptually the idea did not come through as well as she had hoped. Catherine had the same problem as I did in my work… It can stand alone as a ceramic work, yet the concept is missed by most viewers unless the artist is standing there to explain it. In particular, I enjoyed the attention to detail in her masks. It was obvious that two glazing techniques were used (dipping and painting), and I think they were equally successful in their own ways. I enjoyed the variety of color achieved with the painted glaze, yet the dipped mask has a much stronger presence that demands the attention of the viewer. Would the music actually be playing if the pieces were to be displayed in a gallery? After an explanation, I knew the masks were the symbol for her favorite band, but ironically I didn’t think the music matched the feeling of the work at all. From the masks I got a very spiritual, historical, cultural feeling, while the techno music gave a modern, funky, very ‘separated from other historical music’. Also, the one mask cracked several times and had to be glued back together. Probably a majority of these cracks could have been avoided by careful craftsmanship, so hopefully in the future they wont be such a problem. On the other hand, for this piece I think the cracks actually worked to the artist’s advantage as they added to the ‘ancient feel’ I got while viewing them. The work is overall very successful visually, but I think the concept could have been enhanced in the work itself a little more. Loved these masks!!

Thoughts On Critique/Tisa's Work

Part I :
I thought the critique went very well. Literally everyone in the class participated, which is unusual compared to most other critiques I have been to. It is certainly a good sign about the works that there was a great deal to discuss about each. Listening to everyone's different ideas and feedback about each other's project was definitely inspiring. I enjoyed seeing how different people interpreted the same project. All of my classmates seemed to receive valuable feedback that will surely help them if they wish to push their ideas further and if not, in future projects. Unfortunately, my work was not critiqued on wednesday. Since my initial project was a disaster I was not able to have my second one prepared to be shown for the critique. However, I did benefit from listening to my classmates' critiques. Although it was not about my work, it was still informative for me to see what aspects of each piece my classmates thought were working and which parts could be stronger. I am looking forward to having my work critiqued after seeing the helpful feedback each piece recieved. The only improvement i can think of for critique wold be to have the time divided evenly. I understand this is difficult to do when there is so much to discuss in only a couple of hours.

Part II :
I am writing a response to Tisa's work. For the most part I found her work to be quite intriguing. She had many individual parts to her work that she showed us. Each piece was unique from the others. After Tisa informed us that her work was not conceptually driven but very literal and focused on the aesthetic, I appreciated it more. It was really intended for the viewer to come up and carefully inspect the different parts. I had been searching for a meaning that wasn't there to begin with. I think the faces on certain pieces of her work were what made me search for a meaning. Her work is really about the study of and relationship between materials. It seems to ask the question of where nature ends and man-made begins and how blurred that line can get. The objects all look as if they are ancient. They are very weathered and have a fossilized appearance. Some even look as if they could have been a ceremonial piece from an ancient civilization. I found the pieces that looked like vertebrae to be the most interesting because of the intricate and delicate shape. I think Tisa was successful in her study of materials and attempt to blur the lines of what makes something natural. I wish the beautiful aesthetic quality of the work would be pushed a bit further. Since she has developed such an interesting visual appearance, i think it would be wonderful to see these aesthetic skills applied to a more developed concept. Overall, I think Tisa's work was a successful study of the relationship between materials.

Ben's Blog 3


I think that the crit went very well compared to most that I am involved in at this level. It progressed much further than, "I like this because it reminds me of my grandma's old sofa that smells like soap." I am glad that we got into materials choice and craft and how it interacted with the work or concept. People also contributed a lot and there was constructive crit that was very useful that many are afraid to say for fear of stepping on toes. For me I think that I got what I wanted and that was the dialogue that was created by all of you as viewers. I really didn't expect you all to understand the piece because the experience that it was conceived after is by no means very common but you all danced in and out of the concept very well. I was also happy that it became a dialogue and an interesting one because it was interpreted in your own ways relating to your experiences or beliefs. I think that it confirmed for me that my piece was successful. I do agree with the fact now that the faces should have been more different, but in my original concept they were supposed to be me experiencing others memories and I thought that the faces being altered forms of me would have made that more apparent, seeing that no one really understood that I think I should have made that change. Today's crit = Good.

I really liked Tara's work. I obviously am fascinated by the human body/biology since every one of my projects have involved some sort of biological form. I think that her work effectively created a dialogue and that it kept us interested for a good amount of time. The craftsmanship was also done very well. I liked how we were all wondering whether or not the fetuses were deformed or just interacting on some other level, and just what the piece was about. My affinity for political art is wavering, sometimes I find it interesting and others I don't. I think that not knowing what the piece was about was more fun and created a much more interesting dialogue among us, but on the other hand finding out that it was about agent orange after our whole talk it made an impression. So I am really torn on whether or not I would want to know about that if I were in a gallery setting, because as Joe said it kind of cuts everything short, and with such well made objects I don't know if I would want that myself. I enjoyed the project as it was but some part of me would also like to see another related project that would be more abstract and be super surprising. This project did give me a surprise when I found out what it was but if you wanted it to be known that it was about agent orange, I think that to keep the viewers from cutting it short you have to connect with them through a common experience and move them on a very deep level in order to keep them in the concept and interested in what is happening. All in all I think it came out successful.